Thank you kindly for all the work that you've done on my and my wife's behalf. A big pressure has been taken off our chests

M. Elliot
  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas

Criminal Law - Sentencing in the Local Court

Date: October 08, 2010

Authors: Jana Whitby B.A., LL.B. (Hons.)

Often I am asked by my clients who have been charged with common offences such as assault or drink driving what the likely result will be if they enter a plea of “Guilty”. This is not a question which can be answered with much certainty given that even when to individuals are charged with exactly the same charge, the possible outcome when it comes to that individual’s sentencing can vary according to factors such as in which Local Court the matter is dealt with, which Magistrate determines the sentence, the sentencing options available to the Magistrate and the individual’s subjective circumstances.

Set out below in the following paragraphs, the sentencing options available to the Magistrate when dealing with your case and the individual’s subjective circumstances are elaborated upon.

Clients should keep in mind that the sentencing options available to a Magistrate range from the less serious, a fine, to the more serious, good behaviour bond, to the most serious, suspended sentence and/or a term of imprisonment. This in and of itself creates uncertainty as to the likely sentence an individual will receive for their crime.

Aggravating Factors

The offence for which you have been charged and required to appear before the Local Court may also be aggravated by the following factors:

  • The victim was a police officer, emergency services worker, correctional officer, judicial officer, health worker, teacher, community worker, or other public official, exercising public or community functions and the offence arose because of the victim’s occupation.
  • The offence involved the actual or threatened use of a weapon.
  • The individual has a record of previous convictions.
  • The offence was committed in a group/with others.
  • The offence involved gratuitous cruelty.
  • The injury, emotional harm, loss or damage caused by the offence was substantial.
  • The offence was motivated by hatred for or prejudice against a group of people to which the offender believed the victim belonged.
  • The offence was committed without regard for public safety.
  • The offence was committed while the individual was released on bail.
  • The individual abused a position of trust or authority in relation to the victim.
  • The victim was vunerable.
  • The offence involved multiple victims or a series of criminal acts.
  • The offence was part of a planned or organized criminal activity.

Mitigating Factors

Or mitigated by the following factors:

  • The injury, emotional harm, loss or damage caused by the offence was not substantial.
  • The offence was not part of a planned or organized criminal activity.
  • The individual was provoked by the victim.
  • The individual was acting under duress.
  • The individual does not have any record of previous convictions.
  • The individual was a person of good character.
  • The individual is unlikely to re-offend and has good prospects of rehabilitation.
  • The individual has shown remorse for the offence.
  • A plea of guilty has been entered.

Subjective Factors

The subjective circumstances which are often taken into account by the court during sentencing are:

  • Age.
  • Remorse and/or restitution.
  • Education.
  • Criminal History.
  • Prospects for the future/ likelihood of rehabilitation.
  • History of community service or volunteer work.
  • Economic considerations.  

In Summary

In determining your sentence, the Magistrate weighs up the aggravating factors and mitigating factors involved in the offence, as well as your subjective circumstances. Clearly the various factors listed above could lead to individuals charged with the same offence receiving a different sentence.

Further there is a misconception within the community at large that if this is the first time that you have been brought before the Court for a charge of any type, you will automatically be entitled to a Section 10. (A Section 10 is ordered where a guilty plea is entered and the Magistrate determines that your circumstances warrant the non-recording of a conviction on your criminal record).

In my experience Magistrates are becoming more and more reluctant to grant a Section 10 (even sometimes in deserving circumstances). It is also rare these days that if a Section 10 is granted, it is granted without the imposition of a good behaviour bond under Section 10(1)(b) of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999.  The maximum term of a good behaviour bond that can be imposed by the sentencing Magistrate is 2 years. This means that if you are placed on a good behaviour bond for a certain period of time, you must be of good behaviour and commit no further offences for the duration of that bond. If you do commit an offence during the term of the bond then you may be resentenced with respect to the original offence at the sentencing for the subsequent offence.

Some Magistrates will not award a Section 10 under any circumstances. So even if your think you have a story of note to tell, a Magistrate may not be inclined to grant a Section 10 given that most people that come before the Local Court try to make excuses for their actions (even though they are generally aware that they should not have behaved in the manner which brought them before the court) and have a story which they think is exceptional or unique but which a learned Magistrate has heard raised in their courtroom, time and time again.

Despite the many complexities involved in the sentencing of an individual who has committed an offence, it is more likely that you will receive a favourable result with respect to your individual circumstances by engaging the services of a lawyer to represent you.

Our lawyers are widely experienced and often appear at Local Courts Sydney wide. Our lawyers have the ability to understand what may persuade a particular Magistrate to deal with your matter more leniently than they may otherwise be minded to do should you choose to represent yourself. The benefits of representation cannot be understated when your freedom and/or licence may be at stake.

  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas