Thank you kindly for all the work that you've done on my and my wife's behalf. A big pressure has been taken off our chests

M. Elliot
  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas

Tax Law - Legal Professional Privilege - Protection For Clients

Date: April 11, 2011

Authors: Tony Anamourlis B.A., LL.B., MTaxLaw, GradDipLegPrac, SJD Candidate (La Trobe); ATIA

The legal professional privilege attaches to communications for the purpose of giving and receiving legal advice or for use in existing or anticipating litigation.

It is will accepted that if a person prepares and then make a documentary communication to a legal advisor for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice, that documentary communication attracts legal professional privilege.

Common Law Right

Legal professional privilege is a substantive common law right and unless abrogated by statute, it applies beyond judicial and quasi-judicial proceedings to statutory forms of compulsory disclosure such as the access and information gathering powers under various tax laws such as Section 263 of the ITAA 1936.

ITAA 1936

Contrary to the assertions by the ATO in its access manual the generality of the language of Section 263 of the ITAA 1936 does not displace legal professional privilege. A privileged communication may be oral, documentary or a combination of each.

Dominant Purpose

With respect to documents which are produced or brought into existence with the dominant purpose of its author or the person who authorises its creation for using it or its contents in order to obtain legal advice or conduct or conduct litigation at the time of production attracts legal professional privilege. What is clear is that the person who brings the relevant documents into existence need not necessarily be the one who communicates the document to the legal advisor.

Confidential Information

For the purposes of establishing privilege the dominant purpose for the purpose of privilege is that which was the ruling, prevailing or most influential purpose and the element of paramountcy should be the touchstone. Any communication whether it be oral or written which contains confidential material for use of a privileged purpose attracts legal professional privilege.

Extraneous Information

Any document brought in existence for a privilege purpose which nonetheless contains information extraneous to that purpose is still able to attract legal professional privilege. The document is characterised as a whole.

Reports

This also applies to any reports prepared as a pre-requisite for advice or other documents prepared as a pre-requisite for advice on which advice would be based or which are required for the carrying out of the legal work. This applies even if the report or document is required or commissioned by the lawyer. Third party prepared documents for the function of enabling the principal/client to make the communication necessary to obtain legal advice particularly where that Third Party is an expert or technical advisor is also covered by legal professional privilege.

Experts

It should be noted in Pratt, Stone J refers to the fact that with the complexity of present day commerce means that it is increasingly necessary for a client to have the assistance of experts in formulating a request for legal advice and in providing the legal advisor with sufficient understanding of the facts to enable that advice to be given and that the complexity and technicality of the law with taxation legislation now running to many volumes and corporations and securities legislation being similarly mammoth.

  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas