Thank you kindly for all the work that you've done on my and my wife's behalf. A big pressure has been taken off our chests

M. Elliot
  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas

Tax Law - Trusts - Resettlement

Date: October 19, 2011

Authors: Frank Egan B.A., LL.B., A.C.L.A., F.T.I.A. (Notary)

Trusts are being utilised more and more by a wide range of businesses and individuals in our community. Listed unit trusts are being extensively used for either the development and/or acquisition of various property interests. Their popularity continues to grow because accountants promote them as the most effective taxation and asset protection structure currently available in Australia as well as producing substantial fees for them. 

Where trusts are utilised this means the taxpayer is becoming more and more dependent upon their accountant. There is no doubt that taxpayers own nothing but may control everything depending upon how the structure is set up in the first place.  There can be significant compliance costs and these need to be watched.

Danger: Trust Resettlement

There are a number of dangers with trusts and one of them will arise where the trust has been accidentally resettled. In other words, where something is done which is in contravention to the trust deed or where the trust deed is amended in such a way that it contravenes some of the essential terms and conditions of the trust. In a number of tax rulings the Commissioner has recognised that there are a number of complexities and very stringent requirements which demand the exercise of great care when drafting or amending a trust deed.

The ATO's stance

The Tax Office has indicated that there are a number of factors which need to be taken into consideration in determining what may be relevant as to whether a resettlement has occurred. Where a change fundamentally affects the essential nature and character of the trust the trust may resettle and a new one be created. When this happens then it creates real problems.

The Tax Office published in August 2001 a Statement of Principles for the creation of a new trust which provides guidelines when one trust comes to an end and is to be replaced by another. Where a taxpayer is contemplating amending the trust deed it is clear that the trust name; commencement or establishment date of the trust; the identify of the settler, trustee and the identity and nature of the trust do not have to be the same. 

Matters which go to form rather than substance are inconsequential but where it is otherwise they strike at the very heart of the trust relationship and produce dire consequences. That said, these consequences include the realization at the trustee level of the trust property, the loss of carried forward tax benefits, the disposal by the beneficiaries of their interests in the trust and of course stamp duty where a trust is terminated. 

It should go without saying that where amendments to a trust deed are contemplated or trust cloning takes place or a trust is to be terminated then these matters need to be dealt with professionally as the consequences for your accountant, the trustee or the beneficiary can be extremely serious. Currently there is in excess of one million trusts in operation in Australia today but mistakes commonly occur. 

One of the problems is that where a trust has been created a copy of the trust deed and any amendments need to be lodged with the Tax Office. As soon as something goes wrong they are in a position to respond to it as they have or should have the documents. 

Always make sure that where you are contemplating using a trust structure and/or any change to your trust deed(s) or any type of restructuring in which trusts are involved call LAC Lawyers for professional advice and assistance.

 

  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas