Thank you kindly for all the work that you've done on my and my wife's behalf. A big pressure has been taken off our chests

M. Elliot
  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas

Taxation Law - Taxpayers Seeking Advice - Complex Arrangements - Contract

Date: February 04, 2011

Authors: Frank Egan B.A., LL.B., A.C.L.A., F.T.I.A. (Notary)

In the Weekend Financial Review for 22nd and 23rd January 2011 there appeared an article headed “Taxpayers face advice quandary”. The article was written by Katie Walsh and she opines “taxpayers with complex arrangements can be forced to seek legal advice following a recent Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) ruling that has left even tax professionals unsure as to what circumstances would warrant calling the lawyers.

Complex Arrangements – Richard Sinclair v FCT – Deduction for pre-paid interest not allowed

The Tribunal’s ruling cast doubt on whether relying solely on an accountant’s advice for complicated tax matters shows that a lawyer has taken reasonable care. In a decision that has concerned the Accounting Profession, the AAT found Melbourne stockbroker and property developer, Richard Sinclair, had failed to do so because he had not sought the advice of a lawyer rather, he had relied on his accountant’s advice about the construction of a contract which is a legal matter.

Interestingly a number of commentators have been consulted about this. Frankly we are at loss to understand why this would cause consternation amongst taxation professionals. There are situations where accountants are the proper professionals to consult with respect to a taxpayer’s taxation affairs yet there are others which more often than not require clarity or a thorough examination of particular parts of the law which is not and has never been the role of accountants. Over the years accountants have tried steadfastly to wrestle away from the legal professional, taxation law and practice which, to a large measure has been successful. Despite this there are a number of specialist taxation lawyers who only practice in this field and who possess the highest levels of professional competence and expertise. 

The Role of Accountants and Lawyers

Most accountants do a wonderful job on compliance accounting and taxation practice. Sophisticated tax planning including structuring and a full and detailed appreciation of various parts of the tax acts is not their purview and if they have trespassed into this area it is unwise for them to do because they are not legal practitioners. Obviously there are those both accountants and lawyers who recognize that there are some accountants who do possess a high level of taxation competence but that level of competence should not be directed to interpreting other parts of the law but rather to ensure that what they understand as principle relates directly to the application of accounting concepts. It should also be said that where accountants seek to trespass into the area occupied by lawyers they are not at liberty to charge fees for the work performed in this area and they open up a significant professional negligence exposure which is not covered by their professional indemnity insurance arrangements.

Their Roles – Preservation of Rule of Law

What is even more interesting is that those commentators who have been approached about this matter are concerned that the AAT may have got it wrong but if one hesitates for a moment and considers the issue that is likely to lack currency if the AAT sees both accountants and lawyers in action every day of the week throughout Australia. If after due consideration they believe that lawyers should also be consulted in complicated tax matters then who is the accounting profession to say otherwise. Obviously the AAT is recognizing each profession’s special competence. As can be gleaned from our previous articles we think that both professionals add great value to this area and accountants should only be used where accounting matters are at stake and lawyers should only be used where legal advice and representation are required. This does not mean that both professions do not have a legitimate role to play in complicated taxation matters but rather to the contrary that they both make a valuable contribution in settling taxation affairs so that the right outcome is achieved. It should never be said that by using both accountants and lawyers in this area that it imposes an extra level of cost as the roles of both professions are to a large extent mutually exclusive and this is what the AAT has recognized. To deny any person, taxpayer or otherwise the right to seek legal advice about any matter would ultimately destroy the rule of law and disenfranchise the community.

  1. Article
  2. Related Articles
  3. Related Practice Areas